Americas Pastime Baseball Cards

Come visit our baseball card store, America's Pastime 2505 Broadway in Fair Lawn, NJ.


Vintage, Modern & Current Sportscards.

Since 1989 we've stocked a vast inventory of Graded & Ungraded Baseball,Football, Basketball & Hockey cards; Stars & Commons, Pack Boxes, Packs & sets. Autographed items,Sports Memorabilia & Hobby Supplies.


We cater to set builders so please send us your wantlists. 

Come see us at our next card show 

Shows 2022-23

11/26-27 Tarrytown, NY Marriott

12/2-4  Valley Forge, PA

1/14-15/23 Tarrytown, NY Marriott

2/4-5 Cranston, RI

2/25-26 Tarrytown NY Marriott

3/10-12 Oaks, PA

3/31-4/2 Chantilly, VA

4/15-16 Hostra Univ, NY

4/28-30 Wilmington, MA

7/26-30 Chicago National

9/22-24 Oaks, PA

America’s Pastime is a storefront sports card business since 1989, selling vintage & current baseball, football,basketball and hockey cards, hobby supplies,autographed sports items, sports gift items and sports memorabilia with our Bergen County store location since 1989 in Fair Lawn, N.J.


We sell sports cards from all major sports from Vintage years through the present day. We also carry packs and sets of all sports cards. Our vast inventory includes all years of vintage sports cards from the Tobacco era and through the’30’s,’40’s,’50’s,’60’s,’70’s through current day in baseball cards, football cards, basketball cards and hockey cards as well as sports autographs, vintage sports memorabilia and non sports cards. But our focus has always been the vintage baseball cards from Tobacco era through Pre-War baseball cards to the ’50’s, and all sports cards from the ’60’s and ’70’s.

America’s Pastime thrived in the late ’80’s and early ’90’s, survived the tough times of the 1994 strike year and the few years afterwards. The comeback year of 1998 with the Sammy Sosa/Mark McGwire home run chase brought the hobby back and we thrived again for a few years until the 9-11 attacks. Today, we rely on our steady customers from our store location in Fair Lawn, New Jersey. Our regular customers from all over buy vintage sports cards, sports memorabilia and sports autographs from our web site and those that we meet at baseball card shows across the country keep us going and we appreciate all of you.

So if you’re in NJ, stop by and see us at our store on Broadway in Fair Lawn in northern NJ. We’re open 11:30-6 weekdays and 11:30-4 Saturdays. We also set up at many large card shows throughout the country. Stop by our booth and say hello. We display an updated show schedule on our web site. 

We currently have many items listed on our Ebay store under the user name Freddywestie. Please check out our strong feedback record based on thousands of transactions since 2003.

If you have any questions regarding items on our web site you can email or call me anytime, We’re always available to answer your questions, day or night at 201-294-7852.

We thank you all for your business and your trust.

Sincerely, Rich Budnick

© America’s Pastime 2020

Rich Budnick


Here at Americas Pastime we are always looking to upgrade our inventory and are aggressive buyers of all vintage sports cards and sports memorabilia. We are always adding new and interesting items. Our large selection of baseball sports cards and sports cards memorabilia has set builders, star cards and rookie cards collectors from all over asking us to fill their wantlists. So when you’re in northern NJ and looking for baseball cards or Sports Autographs & Sports Memorabilia, come visit our store where we’ve been in business for over 31 years.

Conveniently located in Fair Lawn, NJ close to Garden State Parkway, RT 208, RT 17 and RT 4.

25-05 A Broadway, Fair Lawn, NJ, 07410, US


11:30 a.m.-6 p.m.


11:30 am-4 p.m.